Space Travel News  
Defense Focus: Why buy Russian? -- Part 1

disclaimer: image is for illustration purposes only
by Martin Sieff
Washington (UPI) Dec 10, 2007
Russia has displaced the United States as the world's No. 1 arms exporter not just because its weapons are cheaper, but because many of them are very good.

According to Russian military commentator Nikita Petrov writing for RIA Novosti, in 2007 Russia earned more than $5.5 billion in weapons exports and has a backlog of orders worth more than $20 billion.

Different institutions have different measuring yardsticks for weapons exports and definitions on what they are. However, the U.S. Congressional Research Service estimated Russian arms sales as worth $7.1 billion in its report "Conventional Arms Transfers to Developing Nations, 1998-2005."

The CRS, surprisingly to American eyes, ranked France, not the United States, as the second-largest arms exporter with 2005 sales worth more than $6.3 billion, just ahead of the United States with $6.3 billion.

As we have noted in previous articles, Russia has a number of advantages over the United States in its arms export business:

First, the record global prices for oil and gas, of which Russia is the world's largest combined producer and exporter, have filled the Russian treasury to bursting point, enabling the Kremlin to offer exceptionally favorable payment terms for arms export contracts.

Second, major nations with vastly ambitious armament programs like China, Iran and Venezuela will never buy their weapons from the United States and only reluctantly from U.S. allies, even if they were willing to sell: As all three have huge foreign currency reserves from export earnings, they offer a bonanza to Russian weapons producers.

Third, the volatility of U.S. politics and the well-understood record of successive U.S. congresses in imposing sanctions on previously concluded arms deals makes many countries wary of relying on the United States for their major armaments systems when export of these and their spare parts could be cut off at any time. Indonesian leaders, who recall the U.S. sanctions imposed in 1998 in the row over East Timor, have openly said this was a consideration in their precedent-breaking $1 billion arms deal with Russia.

Fourth, there are major occasions where the U.S. military's obsession with relying on nuclear or exceptionally high-tech systems has literally forced U.S. defense contractors out of some major arms markets.

Also, despite the continuing strategic relationship, including on nuclear issues, developing between the United States and India, India continues to primarily rely on Russia for its major land, sea and air weapons systems, as it has for the past four decades.

One of the most important of these is diesel submarines. The U.S. Navy has not bought any for decades, and no U.S. ship defense contractor has the capability to make them any more. That was why Israel had to turn to Germany to get the three Dolphin-class submarines or U-boats that carry the Jewish state's survivable second strike retaliatory capability of nuclear-armed cruise missiles. And it was why India had to go to France to buy Scorpion submarines to establish the same survivable second strike deterrent against neighboring Pakistan.

Consequently, Indonesia could not have bought its own new fleet of diesel submarines from the United States even if it had wanted to.

However, there is another very obvious and sobering reason why so many countries, including longtime U.S. allies like Saudi Arabia and Indonesia, and a new important partner like India, are turning to Russian weapons systems or continuing to buy them: Many of them, as well as being very cheap, are very good.

(Next: Russian weapons design philosophy)

Related Links
The Military Industrial Complex at SpaceWar.com
Learn about the Superpowers of the 21st Century at SpaceWar.com



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


Israel now the world's fourth biggest arms exporter
Jerusalem (AFP) Dec 10, 2007
Israel has become the world's fourth largest weapons exporter, shipping out arms worth more than four billion dollars so far this year, the defence ministry said on Monday.







  • Russian Carrier Rocket Proton Puts Military Satellite Into Orbit
  • Aerojet Develops Innovative Reaction Control Engine Technology
  • ESA Conducts Vega Main Engine Test In Kourou
  • New Thermal Protection Technologies For Reusable Launch Vehicles To Be Validated

  • Russia Tests Engine For Angara Carrier Rocket
  • United Launch Alliance Launches 2nd COSMO Satellite
  • ATK Receives Contract And Delivers 100th Orion Solid Rocket Motor
  • Arianespace warns US over Chinese space 'dumping'

  • Daunting technical problem mars a good year for NASA
  • NASA pushes shuttle launch into 2008
  • Shuttle Launch Now Targeted For 2nd January
  • Glitch Delays Shuttle Launch Until At Least Saturday

  • Columbus Launch Now No Earlier Than 2nd January
  • New space mission aims to broaden Europe's ISS role
  • Jules Verne ATV Given Its Wings
  • The European Columbus Space Laboratory Set To Reach ISS

  • Kennedy's Desert RATS
  • Voyager 2 Proves Solar System Is Squashed
  • Quails for lunch aboard Atlantis
  • Richard Branson Trains For Virgin Galactic Spaceflight At The NASTAR Center

  • Chang'e-1 Photographs Dark Side Of The Moon
  • China-Made Satellite Navigation System To Support Olympic Games
  • China says space ambitions no cause for foreign concern
  • China To Launch Mars Probe In 2009

  • Honda's ASIMO robot gets smarter
  • Toyota's new robot can play the violin, help the aged
  • Humanoid teaches dentists to feel people's pain: researchers
  • Japan looks at everyday use of robots

  • Building Blocks Of Life Formed On Mars
  • Software Helps Mars Rovers Find Winter Havens
  • Mars Express Watches A Dust Storm Engulf Mars
  • Clues From Antarctica Help With Search For Water On Mars

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright Space.TV Corporation. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space.TV Corp on any Web page published or hosted by Space.TV Corp. Privacy Statement