Subscribe to our free daily newsletters
  Space Travel News  

Subscribe to our free daily newsletters

A Piggyback Solution For Science Versus Exploration

Artist concept of moon bases that NASA plans to establish in the future. Credit: NASA
by David Tenenbaum for Astrobiology Magazine
Moffett Field CA (SPX) Apr 02, 2007
As the drive to explore and colonize the moon switches into high gear, some scientists worry that funding exploration could drain resources away from pure science. One principle of the upcoming manned missions, said Paul Spudis, of the Planetary Exploration Group at Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Laboratory in Laurel, Maryland, is to "try to understand what is involved in cutting the logistical cord with Earth.

Can humans live and thrive off the planet?" Spudis spoke at the February meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, in San Francisco, Calif.

And that is precisely where science enters the picture, contends G. Jeffrey Taylor, professor of planetary science at the Hawaii Institute of Geophysics and Planetology at the University of Hawaii at Manoa. "If you buy into the idea that the important thing is to settle the moon, with plans to go elsewhere, you are stuck with idea that you have to use the resources of space." For settling the moon and beyond, "we will need to use space resources, and science helps us develop those resources."

How can science benefit from a drive to live off the land in space? One key goal for a self-sustaining colony is to find minerals for building material, such as aluminum for habitats. The best known source of aluminum ore is on the lunar highlands, where abundant deposits of plagioclase feldspar average 28 percent aluminum oxide, Taylor says.

Collecting this feldspar could produce a science spin-off, because the lunar highlands are studded with boulders that are remnants of the ancient lunar crust. Although some of these rocks were studied in Apollo samples, "they have not been sampled in enough detail," he says.

One of the most promising lunar resources is helium-3, an isotope deposited by the solar wind that is extremely rare on Earth, but considered a prime fuel for fusion reactors, should such devices ever be developed. Extensive studies by Gerald Kulcinski of the University of Wisconsin - Madison and others have suggested that H3 could be exported to Earth, but it could also be used to generate heat and electricity on the moon. Either scenario would require massive extraction of the lunar regolith - the granular material sometimes called lunar soil.

A regolith-mining project would offer an opportunity to resolve questions that arose from study of samples taken during Apollo and the Soviet Luna landings, which show changes in the ratio of nitrogen isotopes in regolith samples of different ages.

Because the nitrogen in our solar system was originally created within the sun, dating the regolith could lead to a better understanding of the history of the sun - and the moon itself. Portions of regolith have been overridden by lava flows, Taylor says. "If we can date the lava flow, we know the regolith underneath is older."

Furthermore, extracting regolith for resources would expose layers - allowing a lunar stratigraphy that would be too expensive to be supported as pure science.

If these dating activities were widespread, they could be integrated into a stratigraphic chronology of the moon's surface, which could contribute to dating asteroid bombardments - a key question in planetary formation. "Imagine how many layers you would have to look at to build up this kind of 'tree-ring' picture of the moon." Taylor says. "The only way to do that is to have another reason to dig the regolith."

Volcanism also produces pyroclastic flow-a red-hot movement of granular, ashy material. Lunar pyroclastic flows have a high concentration of iron oxide, so they could be mined for ore, or used directly for radiation shielding for habitats.

Preliminary studies suggest that pyroclastic deposits are also enriched in elements that are rare on the moon, including zinc, thallium, chlorine and fluorine. If a moon colony needed to use these elements, the miners could easily document their abundance and distribution, while simultaneously studying physical characteristics of the grains. All of this data could expand our picture of lunar volcanism, further improving our understanding of the satellite's geologic history.

But not every science goal can easily piggyback on resource exploitation. For example, says Clive Neal, an associate professor of geological science at Notre Dame University, geophysics could suffer. "There will be projects that will be difficult to accomplish" from a single outpost on the moon.

The Apollo program found that the moon is shaken about once a year by tremors that exceed magnitude 5, Neal says. Unlike earthquakes, which dissipate within a minute or two, moonquakes can last from 10 minutes to an hour. Global networks to monitor the moon's internal oscillations would "require landings in different locations," Neal says. If humans want to have "a long-term presence, we need to understand these, and that requires least two stations, preferably placed at the two poles."

Although lunar scientists, having benefited from exploration during the Apollo program, seem fairly receptive to the idea of integrating science with resource exploitation, Taylor says scientists and explorers generally work in separate spheres. "You have a whole group that likes to do resource utilization, and another group that does science.

Many scientists think everything should be done for science, but that isn't the only component here. We are going to the moon and Mars to settle, because it helps the country and sparks the imagination, but science could be a great beneficiary. To make the habitats, we will be doing science and resource utilization experiments. Science and the search for resources go hand-hand; there is a very interesting synergism between them."

Related Links
Solar and Lunar Eclipses at Skynightly
Mars News and Information at
Lunar Dreams and more

Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

Assembling Of Moon Mission Spacecraft Begins
Mumbai, India (PTI) Mar 29, 2007
India has begun assembling the spacecraft for Chandrayaan-I, its first unmanned mission to the moon scheduled for 2008, a top space agency official said today. "We have begun the integration process for the spacecraft structure and are putting in place the antennae required for tracking data from this month," S Krishnamurthy, Director of Publicity for the Indian Space Research Organisation, told PTI from Bangalore.

  • Anomalous Behaviour Affects Firing Test Of Vega Zefiro 9 Motor
  • Iowa State To Unveil The Most Realistic Virtual Reality Room In The World
  • Boeing Announces Industry Team For Ares I Crew Launch Vehicle Upper Stage Production
  • Space X Declares Falcon 1 Testing Complete And Ready For Commercial Orbital Transportation Services

  • South Korea Plans To Launch First Rocket In 2008
  • ISRO To Launch Foreign Satellite As Primary Payload First Time
  • Arianespace Is Ready To Support The Mobile Satellite Services Industry's Future Development
  • Next Ariane 5 Takes Shape

  • Shuttle Assessments And Repair Work Ongoing
  • NASA Assigns Crew For Shuttle Mission To Install Japanese Lab
  • Shuttle Atlantis Grounded by Fuel Tank Damage
  • Marshall Communications And AMERICOM GOVERNMENT SERVICES Extend NASA Contract

  • Crew Moves Soyuz To Prep For New Arrivals
  • Next International Space Station Crew To Launch April 7
  • Soyuz TMA-9 Module Relocation Set For March 30
  • MDA To Implement Space Station Berthing Information Solution For Japan

  • NASA Medical Review Team Appointed
  • New Mexico Voters Weigh Spaceport Tax Impost
  • The First Soyuz Mission Forty Years On
  • Researchers Uncover Protection Mechanism Of Radiation-Resistant Bacterium

  • China To Pursue Space Instead Of Socialism
  • China Outlines Space Program Till 2010
  • China To Launch New Direct Broadcast Satellite To Replace SinoSat-2
  • Russian Court Upholds Custody For Space Firm Chief Reshetin

  • Students Rack Up Wins At Local Robotics Competition
  • Talking Bots
  • Novel Salamander Robot Crawls Its Way Up The Evolutionary Ladder
  • Look Ma, No Hands, No Humans

  • NAU Researchers Find Possible Caves On Mars
  • Spirit Studies Rocks in Vicinity Of Home Plate
  • Opportunity Begins Imaging Of Cape Of Good Hope
  • China And Russia Plan Mars Mission

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright Space.TV Corporation. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space.TV Corp on any Web page published or hosted by Space.TV Corp. Privacy Statement