Space Travel News  
US caught between aid and politics over Myanmar disaster

US wants OK before military response to cyclone: Gates
The US military is positioning ships and helicopters to move relief supplies quickly into cyclone-hit Myanmar but not until it has the government's permission, US Defense Secretary Robert Gates said Thursday. Gates said the USS Essex, an amphibious assault ship, is unloading helicopters in Thailand and will then begin steaming to waters off Myanmar to shorten the response time to the crisis. "There is an opportunity here to save a lot of lives, and we are fully prepared to help -- and to help right away," Gates said. "It would be a tragedy if these assets, people didn't take advantage of them." But he added, "I cannot imagine us going in without the permission of the Myanmar government." The State Department earlier did not rule out the possibility of air dropping supplies to victims of the cyclone even without the government's permission. Admiral Michael Mullen, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said supplies could be air dropped but US forces need permission to enter Myanmar's sovereign air space. "It's all tied to sovereignty which we respect whether it is on the ground or in the air. Right now we don't have any way to get into that air space without their permission," he said. Mullen said it would take roughly five days for a four ship naval group led by the Essex to reach Myanmar. He said a joint task force commander was in Thailand to direct a humanitariran relief operation. If Myanmar refuses US help, Washington was prepared to work creatively with other countries to help out, Gates said.
by Staff Writers
Washington (AFP) May 8, 2008
US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice insists aid to cyclone-ravaged Myanmar has nothing to do with politics but critics and some Asian diplomats wonder whether Washington is mixing the two.

The United States has already accorded three million dollars in aid and geared up for massive operations in Myanmar where up to 100,000 people were feared killed by Tropical Cyclone Nargis.

But the country's insular junta has refused to grant access and some critics say a tough US stance at the start might be partly to blame.

The full magnitude of the disaster was not yet known when First Lady Laura Bush held a news conference Monday to denounce Myanmar's military rulers.

Calling them "very inept," she slammed the military junta for failing to respond adequately to the disaster and to issue a timely warning to its citizens as well as for proceeding with a highly criticized constitutional referendum.

"When a country run by a despotic and isolationist regime is laid low by a massive natural disaster, the diplomatic thing to do is to respond with a show of compassion," said Dan Froomkin, the online "White House Watch" columnist for the Washington Post. "Not kick 'em when they're down."

She and President Bush were also criticized for imposing a condition that the junta first allow an American team into Myanmar to assess the scope of the devastation before relief aid could be provided.

"That the International Red Cross, the United Nations, the European Union and a number of highly competent relief agencies were already on the ground doing exactly that did not seem to matter," commented Richard Walden, President of Operation USA, an international relief group.

"Whether it's a hurricane or a cyclone, somehow one Bush or another flies too far above the clouds to feel the pain," he said on Huffingtonpost.com.

Sensing controversy, the Bush administration seems to be backing off but is still insisting that its assessment team be allowed into Myanmar first.

The junta however has not issued visas to the team, currently in Bangkok, worried that any high profile participation could threaten its iron hand rule.

It is "suspicious of the US because of our vitriolic language toward the regime and our call, in effect, for regime change," said David Steinberg, an Asian expert at Washington-based Georgetown University.

The Americans have not been hesitant to use their considerable military and economic resources to help out enemies in times of distress.

When an earthquake flattened the ancient Iranian city of Bam more than four years ago, Washington swiftly provided aid and rescue teams. It also gave immense military support to Indonesia when it was struck by a deadly tsunami in 2004 despite sanctions over human rights issues.

The tone of the initial US response to the Myanmar disaster also surprised some Asian diplomats.

They also saw President Bush's signing Tuesday of legislation awarding a Congressional gold medal to Myanmar's democracy icon Aung San Suu Kyi as untimely amid the devastation and suffering.

"He could have done it a bit later, perhaps on May 27," one Southeast Asian diplomat commented.

The date is the 18th anniversary of the 1990 elections won by Suu Kyi's party and also the date when the military is due to renew her house arrest.

"There is no doubt the junta is heartless but this is not the time to politicize the issue," another diplomat from the region said.

But Rice rejected any notion that politics was at play.

"What remains is for the Burmese (Myanmar) government to allow the international community to help its people," she told reporters.

"It should be a simple matter. It's not a matter of politics. It's a matter of a humanitarian crisis," Rice said. "This is the type of crisis that will only get worse."

Related Links
Bringing Order To A World Of Disasters
A world of storm and tempest
When the Earth Quakes



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


Tsunami offers lessons for Myanmar aid effort
Jakarta (AFP) May 8, 2008
A region closed to the press, a regime reticent to open its borders to aid workers, an overwhelming catastrophe -- there are worrying similarities between Myanmar's cyclone and the 2004 tsunami.







  • Russia's Energomash To Double Production Of Rocket Engines
  • Queensland Uni And NASA Sign Hypersonic Propulsion Deal
  • Rocket Mystery Explained With New Imaging Technique
  • NASA Awards Contract For Engine Technology Development

  • Orbital Awarded Contract for Suborbital Launch Vehicle Research by US DoD
  • Arianespace Takes Delivery Of Its Third Ariane 5 In 2008
  • Skynet 5C And Turksat 3A Are Fueled For The Upcoming Ariane 5 Heavy-Lift Launch
  • ISRO Scientists Meet With Prime Minister

  • Discovery's Payloads Installed
  • Space Shuttle Discovery Arrives At Launch Pad
  • Discovery's Next Move: Rollout to Pad 39A
  • Discovery Ready For Final Assembly And Checkout

  • NASA-TV to televise ISS cargo ship arrival
  • US Congressional Subcommittee Examines The Status Of The ISS
  • Expedition 16's Whitson Hands Over Command Of Station
  • NASA Awards Space Station Water Contract To Hamilton Sundstrand

  • NASA Kepler Mission Offers Opportunity To Send Names Into Space
  • SKorea's first astronaut suffers back injury: doctor
  • Design Begins On Twin Probes That Will Study Radiation Belts
  • SKorea's first astronaut in hospital with back pain

  • Suits For Shenzhou
  • China Launches New Space Tracking Ship To Serve Shenzhou VII
  • Three Rocketeers For Shenzhou
  • China's space development can pose military threat: Japan

  • Canada rejects sale of space firm to US defense firm
  • The Future Of Robotic Warfare Part Two
  • Robot anaesthetist developed in France: doctor
  • Surgeons use robots during heart surgery

  • Phoenix Landing Area Viewed By Mars Color Imager
  • Opportunity Investigates Arthritic Rover Joint
  • Is There Life On Mars - Ask A Magnet
  • Spirit In A Catch-22: Stay Awake Or Sleep

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright Space.TV Corporation. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space.TV Corp on any Web page published or hosted by Space.TV Corp. Privacy Statement