Space Travel News  
Outside View: X-Hour on Iran's nukes

by Pyotr Goncharov
Moscow (UPI) Oct 2, 2007
The Iranian Six have confirmed their commitment to talks with Tehran with a view to removing the concern of the world community with its nuclear program.

But they have warned that if there is no progress, the new resolution against Iran will be put to vote in the U.N. Security Council in November. The Six have found a helpful compromise.

On the eve of the foreign minister meeting on further action against Tehran, the Iranian Six were undergoing crisis. Will they be able to overcome it? If not, it could have most adverse consequences.

As expected, the plan of International Atomic Energy Agency Director General Mohammed ElBaradei to suspend the discussion of tougher sanctions to a later date has caused acute discord among the Six.

Russia and China are refusing to consider new sanctions until the IAEA publishes its report. Moscow and Beijing are convinced that the new sanctions against Tehran will only undermine IAEA efforts to resolve the Iranian predicament. In turn, their opponents in the U.N. Security Council -- the United States, France and Britain -- do not want to delay a draft resolution on tougher sanctions on the grounds that Iran has refused to stop uranium enrichment. The other member of the Six, Germany, sticks to the same position.

It was clear that there will be no consensus either at the upcoming foreign minister meeting of the Six or the Security Council session. What were the potential consequences of this diplomatic confrontation?

The European Trio -- Germany, Britain and France -- may initiate EU unilateral sanctions against Iran, bypassing the United Nations. This would unequivocally mean a split.

French Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner has already spoken about this scenario during his trip to Moscow. At that time his Russian counterpart, Sergei Lavrov, said in no uncertain terms that this step was highly dubious.

Zalmay Khalilzad, U.S. ambassador to the United Nations, poured more oil onto the flames by saying that the agreement on technical cooperation with the IAEA cannot be used as a shield to protect Iran from its violation, lack of cooperation and lack of implementation of the demands of the Security Council on the nuclear issue. He recalled that Tehran had ignored Security Council resolutions twice.

But there is still hope that the Iranian issue will not go beyond the Security Council. U.S. Undersecretary of State Nicholas Burns said that the differences between the Security Council permanent members were tactical. This position could be viewed as readiness for some compromise with Moscow and Beijing if they are also prepared to meet the other side halfway.

China and Russia keep repeating that the Security Council should concentrate exclusively on supporting the IAEA efforts to clear up issues in the Iranian nuclear program. The IAEA has achieved certain results in this respect -- Tehran has promised to resolve these questions in a definite timeframe. In other words, the X-Hour for Iran has been fixed and the countdown started.

This approach is likely to suit the United States, France and Britain, because the X-Hour comes in November or December when the IAEA board of governors will meet for a session. As ElBaradei pointed out, if Iran does not use its chance to resolve all the issues, most probably it will not have such chances in the future.

As expected, Washington offered Moscow and Beijing a compromise -- to fix the deadline in November rather than December.

The rules of the game have been observed.

(Pyotr Goncharov is a political commentator for RIA Novosti. This article is reprinted by permission of RIA Novosti. The opinions expressed in this article are the author's and do not necessarily represent those of RIA Novosti.)

(United Press International's "Outside View" commentaries are written by outside contributors who specialize in a variety of important issues. The views expressed do not necessarily reflect those of United Press International. In the interests of creating an open forum, original submissions are invited.) earlier related report
Iran must come clean soon or stand-off will 'backfire': ElBaradei
Iran must provide key details on its nuclear programme by late November or its unwillingness to work with the international community will "backfire", the UN's nuclear chief said in an interview published Wednesday.

Speaking to the Financial Times from Vienna, Mohamed ElBaradei said that the two key issues that required clarification before he delivered a report to the governing body of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) next month had to do with Iran's research capabilities and its nuclear weaponisation capacity.

"I've told the Iranians: 'This is your litmus test. You committed yourself to come clean. If you don't, nobody will be able to come to your support'," the IAEA director said, referring to a timetable agreed between Iran and the IAEA last month for it to answer outstanding questions about its nuclear programme.

ElBaradei added that if Iran failed to adhere to the timetable, which requires that he present the report on November 22, it would "backfire in their face".

He said that the two major issues that needed to be resolved were Iran's research and development capabilities regarding enrichment, and its capacity to weaponise nuclear matierials.

"I would hope that by November we would have resolved these two issues but I can't say how far we will go ... The key is to show that Iran is acting with us in good faith, with good intentions," he told the business daily.

ElBaradei also defended the deal his agency struck with Iran for the timetable, saying he had not gone beyond his brief, despite reportedly infuriating several major Western powers.

"I was frankly very surprised and concerned that most of the media was hoodwinked into repeating a myth that this was something we had done on our own -- some kind of 'do it yourself diplomacy'."

The Security Council has already passed two resolutions imposing sanctions against Tehran to punish its defiant refusal to heed ultimatums to suspend sensitive uranium enrichment activities.

Iran vehemently rejects charges it is seeking a nuclear weapon, saying the atomic drive is aimed solely at generating electricity for a growing population.

Related Links
Learn about nuclear weapons doctrine and defense at SpaceWar.com
Learn about missile defense at SpaceWar.com
All about missiles at SpaceWar.com
Learn about the Superpowers of the 21st Century at SpaceWar.com



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


Analysis: Iran sanctions expanding
Washington (UPI) Oct 2, 2007
A groundswell of opposition to Iran is pushing U.S. states to divest their pension funds from companies that do business in Iran, and behind-the-scenes political efforts by the administration are paying off with increased European support of government sanctions.







  • J-2X Powerpack Test Article Installed On Test Stand
  • Dawn Of A Long Voyage To The Beginning Of Sol And Beyond
  • Kennedy Prepares To Host Constellation Launch Vehicle
  • India to develop own technology for space travel

  • Pratt And Whitney Rocketdyne's RS-27A Powers New-Gen Imaging Satellite To Orbit
  • United Launch Alliance Launches 75th Consecutive Delta II On USAF 60th Anniversary
  • Russian Space Launch Vehicle Firing Tests Set For 2008
  • Arianespace To Launch Japanese Satellite JCSAT-12

  • Discovery At The Pad For October 23 Launch
  • Strut repairs could delay shuttle launch: NASA
  • Technicians To Begin Discovery Strut Repairs
  • STS-120 To Deliver Harmony Node To ISS

  • Expedition 16 Crew To Launch From Baikonur
  • Successful Test Of Jules Verne ATV Software
  • Space station partners bicker over closure date
  • Space Station Expedition 16 Crew Approved

  • European Agency Offers To Take Indians For A Space Ride
  • Big dreams, few results in private space exploration
  • NASA, NSBRI Select 17 Proposals In Space Radiation Research
  • Space summit looks to the future from India

  • China To Build New Space Launch Center In Southernmost Province
  • China Launches Third Sino-Brazilian Earth Resources Satellite
  • Mission To Moon Not A Race With Others
  • At Least 3 Chinese Satellites Malfunctioning Since 2006

  • Roving The Moon
  • Microsoft teams up in Japan to set robotics standards
  • Drive-By-Wire And Human Behavior Systems Key To Virginia Tech Urban Challenge Vehicle
  • Successful Jules Verne Rendezvous Simulation At ATV Control Centre

  • Spirit Arrives At Stratigraphic Wonderland In Columbia Hills On Mars
  • Duck Bay, Victoria Crater, Planet Mars
  • Are manned missions needed to explore Mars and beyond
  • Spirit Makes Progress Across Home Plate

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright Space.TV Corporation. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space.TV Corp on any Web page published or hosted by Space.TV Corp. Privacy Statement