Space Travel News  
Northrop Grumman KC-45: Why We Won - Strengths And Weaknesses

File image.
by Staff Writers
Washington DC (SPX) May 20, 2008
The U.S. Air Force found Northrop Grumman's bid to build the next generation of aerial refueling tankers superior to Boeing's in four of the five most important selection criteria.

Despite this fact, the losing bidder wants the Government Accountability Office to overturn the Air Force decision to award the contract to Northrop Grumman even though the Air Force conducted what even Boeing described as a fair, open and transparent bidding process.

Here is another reason Northrop Grumman won, drawn from a list of facts included in a redacted version of a protected Air Force selection document.

Strengths and Weaknesses
Boeing likes to claim that its proposed aircraft was rated better than Northrop Grumman's winning KC-45 tanker, stating that it was rated superior to Northrop Grumman on 98 items - called "discriminators" - while Northrop Grumman was superior on 30.

But discriminators are not just "added up" - they vary greatly in significance. Instead of focusing on the most important discriminators, Boeing is counting items that the Air Force judged were much less critical to the KC-X's core mobility mission.

In all, the Air Force identified approximately 800 requirements of varying importance. And the Air Force Request For Proposal (RFP) made clear that it considered Aerial Refueling and Airlift to be the two most important performance criteria.

In these critical categories - which go to the heart of the KC-X mission - Northrop Grumman was clearly superior to Boeing, attaining a two-to-one advantage in key discriminators.

Where were Boeing's advantages? They were in less critical areas like having more interior electrical outlets, better flight deck seats, and the ability to carry secondary, rarely-used fuels - like Swedish Kerosene.

How do more electrical outlets stack up against increased fuel offload over range? How do better flight deck seats compare to greater airlift capability? The conclusion is obvious. The Air Force made clear what its priorities were in the RFP, rated the two competitors, and selected the KC-45.

Related Links
The Military Industrial Complex at SpaceWar.com
Learn about the Superpowers of the 21st Century at SpaceWar.com



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


Possible 4.5 billion dollar fighter sale to Romania: Pentagon
Washington (AFP) May 19, 2008
The Pentagon notified Congress on Monday of the possible sale of 48 F-16 fighters to Romania as part of a deal valued at 4.5 billion dollars.







  • North Carolina Students Win National Team America Rocketry Challenge
  • NASA Successfully Completes First Series Of Ares Engine Tests
  • NASA Awards Contract For Ares I Mobile Launcher
  • Russia's Energomash To Double Production Of Rocket Engines

  • Sweden Launches MASER 11 Sounding Rocket
  • Spaceport Kourou Welcomes Fourth Ariane 5 Launch Campaign For 2008
  • Orbital Awarded Contract for Suborbital Launch Vehicle Research by US DoD
  • Arianespace Takes Delivery Of Its Third Ariane 5 In 2008

  • Discovery's Launch Date Confirmed: May 31
  • STS-124 Astronauts Wrap Up Launch Rehearsal
  • Discovery's Payloads Installed
  • Space Shuttle Discovery Arrives At Launch Pad

  • NASA TV Airs High-Def Day In The Life Of An ISS Astronaut
  • Russian cargo ship docks with the ISS: report
  • MDA Receives Information Solution Contract With Boeing
  • NASA Extends Space Station Contract With ARES

  • ESA Astronaut Recruitment Now Open
  • NASA Seeks Industry Partners For Innovation Transfusion Program
  • On The Moon Inhaling Is A Silent Affair
  • NASA: ISS to soon have new water system

  • Suits For Shenzhou
  • China Launches New Space Tracking Ship To Serve Shenzhou VII
  • Three Rocketeers For Shenzhou
  • China's space development can pose military threat: Japan

  • Robot conducts Detroit orchestra
  • Canada rejects sale of space firm to US defense firm
  • The Future Of Robotic Warfare Part Two
  • Robot anaesthetist developed in France: doctor

  • Rendezvous With Mars
  • Phoenix Probe Due To Touch Down On Martian Surface
  • Phoenix lander set for May 25 touchdown on Mars: NASA
  • Phoenix Ready For Northern Mars Polar Landing

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright Space.TV Corporation. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space.TV Corp on any Web page published or hosted by Space.TV Corp. Privacy Statement