Space Travel News  
BMD Focus: SM-3s are 'mature'

disclaimer: image is for illustration purposes only
by Martin Sieff
Washington (UPI) Nov 8, 2007
By any standards, the Aegis Weapons System and its Raytheon Standard Missile 3s that carried out outstandingly successful double exoatmospheric kills off Kauai in the Pacific Ocean Tuesday is a mature ballistic missile defense technology.

Lockheed Martin noted in a statement that the Aegis Weapon System "is currently deployed on 83 ships around the globe with more than 20 additional ships planned or under contract. In addition to the U.S., and Japan, Aegis is the maritime weapon system of choice for South Korea, Norway, Spain and Australia. Japan began installation of Aegis BMD in its Kongo-class Aegis destroyers in 2006."

Riki Ellison, president of the Missile Defense Advocacy Alliance, spelled out in a statement the significance of Tuesday's test, which was carried out by the U.S. Missile Defense Agency and the U.S. Navy.

"These intercepts mark the 4th different missile defense intercept in 39 days from the U.S. Missile Defense Agency, a remarkable feat both technically and logistically," Ellison said.

"This type of increased continued success, matched now with the initial proven ability to defeat salvo or multiple firings of ballistic missiles, sends a serious and credible message to Iran, North Korea and those that seek to exploit proliferation. Both North Korea and Iran have launched multiple short range ballistic missiles in their previous and documented testing and both of these countries border international waters," he said.

Ellison further noted that the Aegis Sea-Based missile defense system was currently deployed on three U.S. Cruisers and six U.S. Destroyers. Each of these ships has a missile load capability of up to 90 (SM-3s) for destroyers and up to 122 for cruisers."

Further, he added, "This Sea-Based Intercept marked the 10th and 11th successful missile intercepts tests for the Aegis Ballistic Missile Defense System. These tests mark the 32nd and 33rd successful "hit-to-kill" intercepts since December of 1999, when President Bill Clinton enacted into law that the United States deploy missile defense as soon as it is technically feasible."

The implications of these figures and that record are startling, though some of them are not immediately apparent.

They make clear that BMD systems are indeed a mature technology with a probable major rate of anticipated success against short-range and probably intermediate-range ballistic missiles, though two caveats have to be added.

The first is that however well even mature technologies perform in tests, reality is always different. The inevitable laws of entropy and chaos apply in war, as the great 19th century Prussian military theorist Carl von Clausewitz pointed out.

Clausewitz, significantly, came to this conclusion decades before the Northern Irish physicist Lord Kelvin defined the nature of the universe to slide towards chaos, or entropy, in his Second Law of Thermodynamics. During World War II, U.S. GIs fighting around the world more informally codified it as Murphy's Law -- anything that can go wrong will go wrong.

However, the Second Law of Thermodynamics is an equally opportunity employer: It plays no favorites. Things can go wrong for the other side as easily as they can for us. And the more intermediate range BMD programs such as the Aegis system and its Standard Missile-3s are tested, the more statistical likelihood there will be that they will work well in practice, too.

The same consideration applies to the far more difficult but even more strategically vitally Ground-based Mid-course Interceptor program to defend the United States from the threat of nuclear-armed intercontinental ballistic missiles fired by some rogue state.

The second caveat is that the very impressive results already achieved by the SM-3, the Patriot PAC-3, the Israeli Arrow and other BMD systems to protect against short and intermediate range ballistic missiles do not translate into increased capability or reliability for the GBI program against ICBMs.

The GBI program is indeed back on track -- an especial testament to the efforts of Lt. Gen. Henry "Trey" Obering III, the head of the MDA, and his deputy, Maj. Gen. Patrick O'Reilly, and the main U.S. defense contractors, to return to the engineering basics that hard-charging but reckless political Pentagon bosses abandoned in the weary years of the Bush administration.

BMD against ICBMs is possible and achievable, too. And it too has also already been achieved in successful tests. But it is a far higher and more difficult technical mountain to climb. That caution needs to be remembered as Tuesday's very real achievements are celebrated.

Related Links
Learn about missile defense at SpaceWar.com
Learn about nuclear weapons doctrine and defense at SpaceWar.com
All about missiles at SpaceWar.com
Learn about the Superpowers of the 21st Century at SpaceWar.com



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


BMD Watch: S. Korea plans BMD exercises
Washington (UPI) Nov 6, 2007
The Chosun Ilbo cited a South Korean military official as saying that the South Korean navy would put on its training courses exercises about tracking ballistic missiles and submarine-launched missiles against ground targets. The much-criticized, long-troubled Space Based Infrared System is reeling from a new development problem that will take six months and $400 million to fix. But the good news is it won't cost the billion bucks that analysts at first feared. The U.S. Navy is pushing ahead with its controversial plans to convert four nuclear-powered Ohio-class ballistic missile submarines, or SSBNs, into cruise missile submarines, or SSGNs, StrategyPage.com reported Saturday.







  • ATK Selects Avionics Contractor For Ares I First Stage
  • Kelly Space Launches Indoor Rocket Engine Test Service
  • Opportunity Studies Rock Composition And Changes In Atmosphere
  • SpaceDev Completes Milestone Under NASA Space Act Agreement

  • Arianespace's 5th Ariane 5 Mission Is Cleared For November 9 Liftoff
  • ESA To Provide Essential Launch Control Services To EUMETSAT
  • Skynet 5B Satellite Ready For Launch On 9th November
  • China May Use Long March 3 For Lunar Landing

  • Discovery's Return Marks Completion Of Esperia Mission
  • NASA's Space Shuttle Atlantis To Move To Launch Pad Saturday
  • Shuttle returns safely to Earth after complex mission
  • Good weather expected for shuttle landing Wednesday

  • Discovery Mission Readies Station For International Partner Labs
  • Friday Spacewalk To Prepare For PMA And Harmony Moves
  • ISS astronauts prepare Harmony module for permanent docking
  • Korean Astronaut To Ride On Soyuz April Flight With ISS Crew 17

  • Rosetta Closing In On Earth Again For Second Gravity Boost
  • Repair Shops For Broken DNA
  • Spaceship Mockup
  • Malaysia may buy Russian space rocket

  • China to accept private funding for lunar missions
  • China Denies Timetable For Space Station
  • China targets space station in 2020: report
  • China's Lunar Probe Completes Last Orbital Transfer Before Leaving Earth

  • Can A Robot Find A Rock. Interview With David Wettergreen: Part IV
  • Proton Rocket To Launch Glonass Satellites Friday
  • QinetiQ Establishes Service And Support Centre For Talon Robots In Australia
  • UCSD Researchers Give Computers Common Sense

  • Opportunity's Second Martian Birthday At Cape Verde
  • Mars Express Probes The Red Planet's Most Unusual Deposits
  • Spirit To Head North For The Winter
  • Opportunity Studies Bathtub Ring In Victoria

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright Space.TV Corporation. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space.TV Corp on any Web page published or hosted by Space.TV Corp. Privacy Statement