Subscribe to our free daily newsletters
  Space Travel News  

Subscribe to our free daily newsletters

ASAT Weapons And Doctrine In The Early 21st Century Part One

China accuses U.S. of double standards
China accused the United States of double standards Thursday after the U.S. Navy destroyed a dying spy satellite before it fell to Earth. The People's Daily newspaper was critical of the mission, accusing the U.S. government of trying to win a military advantage in space, while criticizing other nations for their space ambitions, the Financial Times reported. The Financial Times said the United States rejected suggestions it was using the failed satellite as an excuse to conduct an anti-satellite weapons test. The United States was sharply critical of China last year for destroying an aging weather satellite in space (pictured) without providing advance notice.
by Yury Zaitsev
Moscow (UPI) Feb 22, 2008
H-hour -- the time American spy satellite USA-193/NROL-21 had to fall -- was calculated for March 6. Where the crash would have taken place would have been unknown until the last moment. A more or less accurate site can be established only an hour or two before a satellite enters the denser atmosphere.

In an attempt to control the process, the United States decided to destroy the satellite with sea-based interceptor missiles. It successfully did so on Wednesday.

Instances of uncontrolled de-orbiting of satellites, including ones weighing a good deal, are not rare. In January 2002 the Extreme Ultraviolet Explorer, weighing some 3.5 tons, fell to Earth. Most of its fragments burned up in the air, while some smaller parts fell into the ocean. America's Skylab and Russia's Salyut-7/Cosmos-1686 -- each weighing 10 times as much as USA-193 -- also went rogue.

In 50 years of space exploration hundreds of satellites have crashed down, but no incidents involving loss of human life or material damage have been reported.

Anatoly Perminov, head of the Russian Space Agency Roskosmos, was thus ignoring history when he endorsed the American decision. His arguments that satellite remnants "could kill a person, damage a house or hit an oil storage tank, producing a chain of further disasters" are not credible.

So what is behind the decision to shoot the crippled satellite down with a missile?

The reason given -- to destroy a fuel tank containing half a ton of frozen hydrazine -- does not hold water. Hydrazine is a fuel used by launch vehicles, including Russia's Protons. In crash landings, it usually burns up in the lower atmosphere, with the rest reaching the Earth with missile debris. That is not very comfortable, but not deadly. In the case of USA-193, the probability of a thin-walled tank 1 meter in diameter reaching the ground is practically zero.

When Russian cosmonaut Vladimir Komarov made a crash landing, his descent capsule, weighing 3 tons, measuring more than 6 feet across and protected with a massive heat shield was completely melted. Only the titanium frame survived. And what was left of Columbia as it burned when de-orbiting?

The American administration is anxious to destroy the satellite for a different reason, or rather two reasons.

The first is to keep what the satellite contains secret. The only thing known about it is that it belongs to the U.S. National Reconnaissance Office. The spacecraft was designed to test new technologies for the development of spy satellites of a new generation.

Photometric measurements failed to identify any solar panels on USA-193. It may well be that they did not unfold as the craft separated from its launch vehicle. Some experts, however, believe that they were not provided in principle because the satellite was powered by a nuclear reactor. In which case matters could take a nasty turn.

(Yury Zaitsev is an analyst at the Russian Academy of Sciences' Institute of Space Research. This article is reprinted by permission of RIA Novosti. The opinions expressed in this article are the author's and do not necessarily represent those of RIA Novosti.)

(United Press International's "Outside View" commentaries are written by outside contributors who specialize in a variety of important issues. The views expressed do not necessarily reflect those of United Press International. In the interests of creating an open forum, original submissions are invited.)

Related Links
Military Space News at

Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

US Hits Rogue Spy Satellite With Missile
Honolulu, Hawaii (AFP) Feb 20, 2008
The US Defense Department said late Wednesday it had successfully used a ship-board missile to shoot down an out-of-control spy satellite before it plummeted to Earth.

  • Iran gives details on controversial space launch
  • Gearing Up For World's Largest Rocket Contest
  • Jules Verne ATV Launch Approaching
  • Propulsion Technology Mostly Unchanged After 50 Years

  • Japan successfully launches high-speed Internet satellite
  • Arianespace Mission Update: The ATV Has Been Integrated On Its Ariane 5 Launcher
  • ILS Proton Launches THOR 5 Satellite
  • Bigelow Aerospace And Lockheed Martin Converging On Terms For Launch Services

  • US space shuttle Atlantis returns home
  • Shuttle Launch Postponed Due To ET Delays And Solar Energy Shortage
  • STS-122 Prepares For Landing
  • Atlantis leaves space station after making it more European

  • UN says its flag to be flown to space station
  • Columbus External Experiments Installed During Spacewalk
  • Astronauts complete successful spacewalk
  • Schlegel Completes First Spacewalk

  • Hobbyists track secret orbits of spy satellites
  • NASA Partners With Orbital Sciences For Space Transport Services
  • Britain considers manned space missions
  • Space Executive Course Provides Pinpoint Space Education For Leaders

  • China to launch second lunar probe in 2009: report
  • Shenzhou VII Spaceship Airlock Module, Spacesuit Pass Initial Ground Tests
  • China set to launch record number of spacecraft in 2008: report
  • China May Broadcast First Taikonaut Spacewalk Live

  • Robot Plumbs Wisconsin Lake On Way To Antarctica, Jovian Moon
  • Can A Robot Draw A Map
  • Meet Blob The Robot
  • Russian Fuel Flows Into Jules Verne Automated Transfer Vehicle

  • Unique Martian Formation Reproduced, Reveals Brief Bursts Of Water
  • Mars study shows oceans of water bubbled up from below
  • Spirit Inches Downward Into Final Winter Perch
  • Mars Rovers Sharpen Questions About Livable Conditions

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright Space.TV Corporation. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space.TV Corp on any Web page published or hosted by Space.TV Corp. Privacy Statement