Subscribe to our free daily newsletters
  Space Travel News  

Subscribe to our free daily newsletters

Falcon 1 Video Suggests Stage Collision

Image grab from Space X video feed after first stage separation.
by Greg Zsidisin
Casper WY (SPX) Mar 22, 2007
The video of the SpaceX "Demoflight 2" launch this week in the South Pacific appears to show a serious staging anomaly that, if confirmed, would likely need to be addressed before the next flight of the Falcon 1 vehicle. In response to an email, Gwynne Shotwell, SpaceX Vice President of Business Development, disagreed with the anomaly assessment. "There was no anomaly there. We knew the second stage would kick a bit after separation. There was no contact from initial look."

Onboard video of the orbital launch strongly suggests, however, that there was a collision between the top of the first stage and the exit cone on the second stage at staging. Less than 15 seconds after staging, a structural ring near the bottom of the cone can be seen disintegrating, possibly as a result of the collision.

It is not known what, if any, effect a collision and the ring disintegration might have had on the vehicle, which failed to reach orbit after what SpaceX has described as a roll control problem. A control issue is evident as a conical oscillation of increasing severity towards the end of the released video, although it appears mostly to involve pitch and yaw, with the roll position holding relatively steady.

On the video (currently available at spacex), staging occurs at the displayed T+2:51 point (3 minutes 28 seconds from the start of the video as published). From the point of view of the camera on Stage 2, Stage 1 skews to the left as it separates, and appears to strike the end of the exit cone with a significant "bump".

It is unclear, however, whether Stage 1 initially runs into Stage 2, or vice versa. Stage 2 skews, as is evident by the background, before its exit cone makes a large, quick shift to the right at Stage 2 ignition, and the stage appears to resume its previous course.

A structural ring at the base of the exit cone begins to noticeably peel away beginning at T+3:07, at approximately the location of the perceived strike. The entire ring comes off as a unit at T+3:14, just as a mission commentator announces "Coming up on fairing separation."

The exit cone position and background show a circular oscillation, consistent with a coning motion, beginning around T+4:20. This oscillation markedly worsens until the end of the video at T+5:01. Despite an announcement of "Telemetry lock on both stages" just before this point, SpaceX has said that telemetry and vehicle tracking were lost at about this time.

Possible scenarios in which a collision with the Stage 2 exit cone would affect the vehicle guidance control include damage to Stage 2 thrust vector actuators. Direct structural damage to the Stage 2 exit cone could also possibly have affected control, especially if it resulted in a changed and/or varying thrust angle due to cone asymmetry and out-of-round condition, especially after the loss of the structural ring.

The launch was the second attempt by SpaceX to fly its Falcon 1 small launch vehicle into orbit. Almost exactly a year before, the first Falcon 1 vehicle failed shortly into its first stage burn, crashing back into the atoll from which it was launched. Despite the launch problems and failure to reach orbit, SpaceX claimed success.

In an online update on the SpaceX website, founder Elon Musk stated "We retired almost all of the significant development risk items," listing staging as one such milestone. "This test has flight proven 95+ percent of the Falcon 1 systems," he asserted.

Related Links
Rocket Science News at Space-Travel.Com
Rocket Science News at Space-Travel.Com

Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

SpaceX Set To Try Again Today
Washington (AFP) March 20, 2007
Private satellite carrier SpaceX will launch its Falcon 1 rocket into space from the Marshall Islands Tuesday, nearly a year after its first attempt failed, the company said in a statement.

  • Falcon 1 Video Suggests Stage Collision
  • SpaceX Set To Try Again Today
  • Students Rocketing Into History At Wallops
  • NASA Glenn To Test Orion Crew Exploration Vehicle

  • Arianespace Is Ready To Support The Mobile Satellite Services Industry's Future Development
  • Next Ariane 5 Takes Shape
  • Official Opening Of The Soyuz Launch Base Construction Site In French Guiana
  • Canadian Satellite Given Final Checks At Russian Launch Pad

  • Marshall Communications And AMERICOM GOVERNMENT SERVICES Extend NASA Contract
  • Shuttle's External Tank Inspection And Repairs Continue
  • Shuttle ET Repairs Continue
  • Repairs Underway Of Hail Damaged Shuttle External Tank

  • ISS Orbit Successful Changed Ahead Of Soyuz Docking
  • Nespoli Focuses On Complex Mission For ESA
  • ISS Orbit To Be Adjusted March 16
  • Station Crew Perform Experiments Related To Human Adaptation To Space

  • Engineers Create SpaceNet - The Space Exploration Supply Chain
  • Dr. Charles Simonyi To Take Gourmet Meal To Space
  • European Astronauts In Rome For The 50th Anniversary Of The Rome Treaties
  • Flying A Flag

  • China Outlines Space Program Till 2010
  • China To Launch New Direct Broadcast Satellite To Replace SinoSat-2
  • Russian Court Upholds Custody For Space Firm Chief Reshetin
  • China Unveils New Space Science Plan

  • Students Rack Up Wins At Local Robotics Competition
  • Talking Bots
  • Novel Salamander Robot Crawls Its Way Up The Evolutionary Ladder
  • Look Ma, No Hands, No Humans

  • Mechanized Explorers Study The Depths, Chemistry Of Mars
  • NASA Scientists And Teachers To Study Mars In The Mojave Desert
  • Spirit Loses And Then Re-Establishes Contact with Orbiter
  • Express Logic Plays Key Role In Managing MRO Data From Red Planet

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright Space.TV Corporation. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space.TV Corp on any Web page published or hosted by Space.TV Corp. Privacy Statement